Church Pastors and Staff

Dr. Michael Gardner, Senior Pastor
Old Mission’s senior pastor grew up in the Hyde Park area of Kansas City, and after a brief detour into small town living during his High School years, the Kansas City area has always been home. He served two previous appointments as Lead Pastor in Western Shawnee and Olathe, and also churches in Coffeyville and Dodge City. His previous eight years before Old Mission were spent as Senior Pastor of First United Methodist Church in downtown Wichita, where his messages reached up to 30,000 viewers a week through their television ministry at KAKE-TV. Mike has degrees from Baker University, St. Paul School of Theology and an earned doctorate from Drew University. Mike has been married to Ann, the love of his life, since 1978, and they have four adult children, and nine grandchildren. Mike and Ann live not far from Old Mission in old Leawood. Mike's life verse for forty years is Matthew 5:16; "Let your light so shine before men that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father in heaven."  You can find out more about his thoughts on life and faith in Dr. Gardner's blog at

Rev. Karen Nyhart, Associate Pastor
Karen was appointed to Old Mission in 2005. She presently serves as Clergy for Christian Education. Karen received a Bachelor of Science in Elementary Education from Olivet Nazarene University and a degree in Christian Education from Perkins School of Theology at Southern Methodist University. She was ordained in 2003. Prior to serving at Old Mission, Karen served at Keller UMC in Texas for seven years. Karen spends much of her leisure time with her husband Scott and her three adult children. She enjoys walking, hiking, reading, water aerobics and attending her children’s activities.

Rev. Leslie Van Blarcom, Minister of Congregational Care
Leslie began her vocational ministry at Old Mission in 1975 in Children's Ministry. She left Old Mission at the end of 1988 and served for 20 years at Shawnee United Methodist as Associate Minister where she worked in Christian Education, Pastoral Care and Mission. We are delighted that an 2012, Leslie returned to the ministry staff of Old Mission, working part-time in pastoral care and congregational care ministries. Leslie believes that relationships are the heart of ministry and this position gives her great opportunity to be a caring presence for members of the Old Mission community in times of need. Leslie regularly leads in worship and also supervises our Congregational Care Ministers. In her free time, Leslie enjoys spending time with her 5 grandchildren, exercising, traveling with her husband Cliff, reading and watching reruns of "Law and Order".

Rev. Wally P. Proctor, Minister of Connections and Welcome
Rev. Wally Proctor joined Old Mission's staff on September 1, 2013. Wally grew up in Waco, Texas, has a Bachelor of Music degree from Wichita State University and a Master of Music from Eastern Illinois University. He holds his Master of Divinity degree from Northern Theological Seminary in Chicago. He came to Old Mission from serving United Methodist Churches in Lombard, Illinois, Topeka, Roeland Park, Stillwell and most recently Leawood where he was Senior Pastor before his retirement. Wally is married to Freda Proctor who has been Assistant Professor of Music and Director of Instrumental Musical Studies at the University of St. Mary, in Leavenworth, Kansas for 20 years. Wally and Freda are both accomplished professional and Church musicians. Wally and Freda have three grown boys, Nick, Peter and Jon, and eight grandchildren. They live on a horse farm in Wyandotte County, Kansas. Wally has special skills and training in teaching and preaching, worship, leadership and family systems. He also has a passion to connect people to God and to one another. Dr. Gardner, who has known him for more than thirty years, says, "To know Wally you need to know his two passions. He is both a fisherman and a fisher of men."

Kids will be kids and Mike is definitely a kid at heart. Luckily, he has also got the energy to match that of Old Mission’s youth. A member of the church since age 8, Mike became Youth Director in July of 2007, growing the program steadily each year. About the Old Mission Youth, Mike says, “They’re very caring and love helping others. They’re always ready to talk to me about how their week is going, what’s going on in school, etc. It feels great not only to connect with, but to help guide a younger generation.”

Cassie received a Bachelor's Degree in Liberal Studies with an emphasis in Psychology and Relgion minor from Park University. She also studied Youth Ministry as an undergrad and is working toward her certification in Youth Ministry. Cassie loves working with middle school students because of their energy and passion. She feels that middle school is an important age group to minister to because they are beginning to find their own faith walk apart from their parents' and trying to figure out what their faith means to them. As the Director of Middle School Ministry, she plans and leads Sunday activities and Bible Studies for the middle school youth and helps coordinate and lead other youth events with the Director of Senior High Youth Ministries. In her free time, Cassie loves to spend time with her daughter, seeing the latest box office hit, bowling, or reading a good book. She is also an avid air hockey player and is always looking for a good challenge.

He’s sort of like the Wizard of Oz. You may not see him often, but behind the scenes Larry Bentson keeps very busy. He keeps the finances in order, pays the bills, processes the payroll and generates financial reports for Old Mission. Larry helped to bring members the option of direct deposit for their contributions. He’s also helped to reduce costs by implementing electronic financial statements for people who wish to receive updates by e-mail.

Members, visitors and friends who have filed in and out of the doors at Old Mission for years have come to know Gay Ecton’s smile and “can-do” attitude as a reflection of the church itself. She has been a member of Old Mission for more than four decades. She began working in the church office in 1987. Then in 1995, she moved to the role of Office Administrator. There was a 7 year period of time that she and her husband Reid lived in California. As soon as they were back home, she picked up right where she left off as Office Administrator. “I like the idea that I support clergy, staff and members in their ministry. Old Mission is a caring community, offering opportunities to serve others,” she says.

Amy is our Communications Coordinator / Office Assistant. Her hours are 9 - 4:30 Monday through Thursday. She will be the pleasant voice you hear or face you see at our front desk at Old Mission and serves as the creative source for our communications. Amy was raised in Wamego, KS and moved after high school to Montreal, Quebec, Canada. She has a Bachelor's Degree in French Language from Concordia University. She is a talented musician, having led worship with her husband in their church. Amy and her husband Martin have two sons, Adrien and Olivier. Interests include hiking, biking, traveling, gardening, repurposing, singing, cooking and photography. Stop by and say hello and welcome Amy to our church staff.

Three-year-olds have been learning about Jesus from “Miss Michele” for more than 20 years. In fact, there’s hardly a child at Old Mission who doesn’t know Michele. She showers the wee ones with love, calling each and every child by name — whether they’ve been there one Sunday or 100. She sees God’s spirit in the children of Old Mission. "It’s so important to get the children excited about Jesus — to teach them that He never lets us down or disappoints us — everyone else will, but not Him!” Michele’s passion for prayer has also made her the go-to person for the church’s prayer chain, and she started Old Mission’s prayer shawl ministry which combines her hobby of knitting with prayer for others. Finally, she is also responsible for our Membership and Attendance systems and keeping us on track.

As the only church in Fairway, Old Mission was easy to find when Charlotte Christiansen moved to the area in 1974 and started looking for a church. She has watched her own granddaughters grow up here. Today her grandmotherly love extends far beyond her own family, encompassing all the church’s wee ones in the nursery. It is “the precious children” that she enjoys most about her ministry.

Karen is the primary coordinator of worship, music and the arts at Old Mission. She is known by Old Mission members for her outgoing and warm smile and boundless energy. In addition to coordinating traditional and contemporary worship, Karen is the worship leader at the 9:45 a.m. contemporary worship service. Karen also coordinates children's music in Sunday School, with volunteers, and music for Old Mission's one-of-a-kind Vacation Bible School program each summer. "I love planning worship where people connect to God through music and drama and the arts", she says. "Whether it's designed for children or adults, I enjoy the creative process of praying and studying to design worship that pleases God and speaks to those who participate." Karen works closely with our Senior Pastor in the design of worship.

Teaching children has been a lifelong dream of Old Mission’s Early Education Center Director, who has been a part of the childcare center for nearly 35 years. While the center’s national accreditation is a clear indication that Old Mission is dedicated to providing quality care for kids, Betty Leonard says it’s the family atmosphere that really sets the church’s program apart.

When Tom Gifford walked into Old Mission about ten years ago and heard the bell choir perform at a Sunday morning service, he knew he had found a new church home. His lifelong love of music lead him to become Old Mission’s Chancel Choir Director. Tom was no stranger to the job; he spent years watching his mother in her role as the bell choir director and youth choir director in Nebraska. “Music is one of the most powerful ways God can speak with us,” he says. “Conversely, music is one of the best ways we can communicate with God.”

Being involved with music has been part of Terry's life since childhood. Her dad was the choir director and her mom was the organist at the church they attended in Manhattan, Kansas during her younger years. As a teenager, Old Mission’s Director of Bell Ministry fondly recalls many hours spent with friends in UMYF and playing hand bells. Now Terry leads the charge at Old Mission as the director of Spirit Bells.

The organ is music to her ears. For over 50 years, Old Mission’s Organist has elicited sweet sounds from the church’s pipe organ. In fact, Gloria Slagle is an institution at Old Mission, much like the beautiful instrument she has played week after week, year after year, decade after decade. Gloria is the only full-time organist who’s played the pipe organ that’s graced the church’s sanctuary for over 40 years.